RETURN : RESTAURANT REVIEW 
4 STARS / 5  (EXCELLENT)
CHEF : MATT LAMBERT 
VISITED JUNE 2026 
AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND 
 
 
If you're a New Zealand chef who's done great in New York, returning to resume your career in a country of five million people in one of the most physically isolated nations in the world, may not be considered the greatest of career ideas. But Matt Lambert and his wife and business partner Barbara Lambert have pulled off this admirably special move, and New Zealand is better off for it. The last decade has seen the decline of fine-dining in Auckland, and if "Return" is going to continue its sophisticated operation, it will rank as a valuable addition bolstering Auckland's fine-dining ecosystem to keep its game up. 
 
"Return" is located in the upscale central suburb of Ponsonby. It doesn't look like much from the outside but step inside the extra-height space and the refined spacious interiors quickly make an impression, not unlike some well-built Kiwi residences which look modest on the outside but pack impressive real estate within. The front has beautiful tables with table-lamps, with the high wall on one side finished in wood veneer, its mid-section taken up by a full-height mirror that adds a design flourish. At the back, there's a central bar area around which there are other tables. White tablecloth, very rare in Auckland now, is thankfully present here. Seats are a mix of somewhat spartan ones at the front, while the back area has more comfortable fully cushioned ones with armrests, whereas I rested on a snug banquette. The wooden floor is fairly commonplace. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Apart from the compact a la carte, there is a 5 course $165 "short story" tasting menu (with extras like bread and petit fours) and a 9 course $225 "long story" degustation. I wanted the latter, so as to experience as much of the range as possible, but they could not offer it to me as I do not eat red meat, so they offered a modified version of the "short story" menu with two courses of the chef's choice added at extra charge (so $165 + $38 + $20 = $223). 
 
I thought of adding a second visit to additionally sample the a la carte for this review, but then realized that if you can't provide a good enough synecdoche with seven courses, then more is unlikely to swing the needle. A "chicken and egg" main course caught my eye in the a la carte section but not much else. There is no dedicated vegetarian section listed on the menu, a conspicuous omission for a restaurant that may want to be something more than just another meat paradise. 
 
The opening bite was "Fish & Chips" - a wafer decorated with garnishes, this was shatteringly crisp - just a whisper of the fish within, but really the aim of this was to present the fish, chip, acidic element - all of them - in one crunchy bite. The amuse bouche partner that came alongside it continued the trippy texture game but was tastier - a mushroom mousse atop sourdough cracker. Silken smooth, the richness of this mushroom preparation evoked high-quality chicken or duck liver pate. 
 
 
 
 
 
Tuna crudo, with "three types of radish", presented as interlocking petals, spoke in whispers I could not hear or care to hear. Two supplemental dishes I had requested to build a longer menu and which the chef added based on his choice, were unremarkable. 
 
 
 
 
Ora Salmon was presented as three small circular cuts, each prepared differently but was not worth its $38 charge. Salmon belly mousseline was too subtle for its own good, ditto the fish cured in citrus, but the seared salmon had a beautiful depth of flavour, simply bewitching in its cured roasted notes, ocean-miles away from regular salmon, gone in two bites. 
 
 
 
 
The whitebait ($20) continued the long line of tasteless white bait I've had in NZ (the exception being the one served by Henry Onesemo). It was bathed in textbook-perfect brown butter sauce. On the side came a glossy hunk of milk bread, seven sections you could pull apart - tasty, fresh and soft with echoes of good garlic bread - and too big for me to finish in this meal. 
 
 
 
 
 
I deliberately visited on a Tuesday night to see the logistics on a more merciful evening. There was a liberal smattering of patrons, enough to keep the staff occupied. In some long degustation meals in some other fine-dining restaurants, when I needed service for one thing or the other, I've been left searching for a long time for staff. Not here, where the service level, monitored by just two polished youngsters (a gentleman and a lady) was so high, that I wanted for nothing (Barbara Lambert oversees the front of house). Dishes just flew out of the kitchen, my meal was over in two and a half hours, and the staff was so attentive and smoothly energetic that it was one of my best service experiences in Auckland.
 
Matt Lambert made multiple appearances in the dining room. I managed to have a chat with him and he was particularly kind to me ("Call me Matt" he said, when I addressed him as 'Chef Lambert'). I was given a complimentary glass of chilled delicious Riesling ("a friend of ours grows this", the staff told me) but I can report to you, dear reader, that this freebie did not sway my rating of this restaurant. The well-stocked alcohol list has a good wine selection (including a fine Te Kano Pinot Gris I enjoyed) along with many house-special cocktails.  
 
Return to the standard "short story" tasting menu from the detour of added dishes, and 'Return' returned to good times. Dry aged duck breast was aduckquately tender - pulling off the enormous achievement of not being chewy which even top chefs in Auckland often cannot ensure, with a strong demi-glace sauce that had vegemite-like intensity. 
 
 
 
 
Sometimes one dish in a restaurant changes the equation and makes you reconsider what a kitchen is truly capable of when it fires on all cylinders. The snapper main course featured - lo and behold what a great surprise ! - unremarkable snapper with its trademark middling flavour and a lame selection by the kitchen for the fish dish. But everything else in the dish evoked hosannas for manna. The fish was covered by broad blankets of a green "herb crust" that was not just herbaceous but also gently toasty and deeply delicious. Underneath the fish was a medley of delights: finely chopped brussel sprouts, bits of prawn and also pomegranate ! with a neat beurre blanc sauce tying the overall package to deliver beautifully blended bites. 
 
 
 
 
There was no pre-dessert in the "short story" tasting menu, but the main dessert, though unspectacular, offered enough shades of sweet bites to end the meal on a peaceable note. Named "Study of Apple", it lacked a few semesters, but delivered a pleasantly brief lecture, featuring swirling flavours of a lemongrass miso tart atop tarte-tatin-like apple jam, balanced by the cooling creaminess of yoghurt ice-cream. 
 
 
 
 
 
Petite fours, dramatically presented on individual blocks of sculpted porcelain with fern etchings amongst other designs, continued to deliver sweets hits, the honeycomb crunch and the nougat particularly notable.  
 
 
 
 
The cuisine, save for that lavish, creatively constructed main course, did not break new flour in terms of dish architecture and vision. But an experience is formed of more than just the food. 
 
Mr.Jim who supervised and administered my meal, along with occasional help from a similarly sharp young lady, conducted my experience here Iike a top basketball player who never misses a single beat for his team and neatly slam-dunks time after time. The food alone would have merited 3.5 / 5, but the superior service elevated the restaurant to 4 Stars out of 5 (Excellent). The last time I gave 4 stars was for Grove's blockbuster group dinners in 2020 & 2024, and Simon Wright's French Cafe in 2012. 'Return' is a promising restaurant that is a very welcome addition to Auckland's fine-dining scene. 
 
 
UPN 
 
 
UPNWORLD welcomes your comments.